GGXLog Forum
generic terms - Printable Version

+- GGXLog Forum (https://www.ggxlog.net/forum)
+-- Forum: My Category (https://www.ggxlog.net/forum/forumdisplay.php?fid=1)
+--- Forum: STUW Data Viz (https://www.ggxlog.net/forum/forumdisplay.php?fid=7)
+---- Forum: Terminology Discussion - Writing Studies and Data Visualisation Book (https://www.ggxlog.net/forum/forumdisplay.php?fid=8)
+---- Thread: generic terms (/showthread.php?tid=2)



generic terms - FloorBuschenhenke - 10-09-2024

Dear contributors and editors, 

Going through the very colourful yellow, green and red sections in our chapter I came across a stumbling block. Some of the terms we used I consider to be very generic, and not part of the research domain (or at least we don't use them to mean something specific to our research domain). A few examples:
sequentiality (simply the (chronological) ordering of events) 
writing pedagogy (the teaching of writing skills)
(writing in the most) natural conditions. (as in 'similar to in real unprompted writing contexts')
dynamic (not static, but changeable)

I feel adding definitions and references for these terms would hinder the reading experience of our future audience. Can I ask if you have similar experiences and/or suggestions for how to handle these terms?


RE: generic terms - Guest - 10-16-2024

(10-09-2024, 07:25 AM)FloorBuschenhenke Wrote: Dear contributors and editors, 

Going through the very colourful yellow, green and red sections in our chapter I came across a stumbling block. Some of the terms we used I consider to be very generic, and not part of the research domain (or at least we don't use them to mean something specific to our research domain). A few examples:
sequentiality (simply the (chronological) ordering of events) 
writing pedagogy (the teaching of writing skills)
(writing in the most) natural conditions. (as in 'similar to in real unprompted writing contexts')
dynamic (not static, but changeable)

I feel adding definitions and references for these terms would hinder the reading experience of our future audience. Can I ask if you have similar experiences and/or suggestions for how to handle these terms?
Thank you, Floor, for your message.

We (the editors) have deliberately marked out the words very broadly in order to see where we can draw the line: which term to choose or not. 
The idea is to give authors the choice of the terms they select as being part of the data visualisation domain linked to the writing process. So no problem: choose precisely the terms and add a definition and references.


RE: generic terms - fbusche - 10-21-2024

[quote pid="5" dateline="1729062931"]
(10-09-2024, 07:25 AM)FloorBuschenhenke Wrote: Dear contributors and editors, 

Going through the very colourful yellow, green and red sections in our chapter I came across a stumbling block. Some of the terms we used I consider to be very generic, and not part of the research domain (or at least we don't use them to mean something specific to our research domain). A few examples:
sequentiality (simply the (chronological) ordering of events) 
writing pedagogy (the teaching of writing skills)
(writing in the most) natural conditions. (as in 'similar to in real unprompted writing contexts')
dynamic (not static, but changeable)

I feel adding definitions and references for these terms would hinder the reading experience of our future audience. Can I ask if you have similar experiences and/or suggestions for how to handle these terms?
Thank you, Floor, for your message.

We (the editors) have deliberately marked out the words very broadly in order to see where we can draw the line: which term to choose or not. 
The idea is to give authors the choice of the terms they select as being part of the data visualisation domain linked to the writing process. So no problem: choose precisely the terms and add a definition and references.
[/quote]

Many thanks for your reply. This clarifies a lot, I will work on providing adequate definitions and references where needed.